Latest from Special City Council Budget Study Session

Thank You, El Cerrito Library Supporters!

On Tuesday afternoon, June 9, the El Cerrito City Council held a Special City Council Budget Study Session.

During this study session, the Council heard and discussed recommendations for programs and services that could be reduced based on previously determined strategic priorities. Reducing El Cerrito Library operating hours from 46 to 35, the minimum hours provided by the County, was one of the reductions recommended.

The City Council also heard Public comment from 103 residents, most all from El Cerrito, but a few from Richmond Annex and Kensington. 49 of these comments requested that library hours not be cut, and that El Cerrito continue funding 11 additional hours so our library will remain open 46 hours, six days a week. (Last month Contra Costa County decided to close all branch libraries on Sundays.)

At the end of the study session, the city council members each spent about 5 minutes providing guidance to city staff and the consultant about the matters presented and to assist staff and the consultants in preparing recommendations for the June 16 council meeting.  Four of the five members (Mayor Lyman, Mayor Pro Tem Fadelli, and Councilmembers Pardue-Okimoto and Quinto all included as part of their statements a statement to the effect that cutting library hours should no longer be considered.

The El Cerrito Library Foundation applauds and thanks each and everyone of you 49 supporters who took the time to make your voices heard. It’s broad based support like this that ensures all of the Councilmembers know that we care, and that we are paying attention to what they are saying and doing.

To receive notices from the City of any City Council meetings, budget discussions, or other City activities please sign up for the notices <>. FYI, the next budget discussion will be during the City Council meeting on Tuesday, Jun 16, 2020. The meeting agenda and packet <> will be available some time Thursday afternoon, June 11.

Al Miller, President, El Cerrito Library Foundation

Thank you for your support – City Council to Maintain Extra Hours for our Library!

At an unusual Saturday morning meeting on April 25, 2020, held to discuss the severe financial crisis facing the city, aided by strong supporting Public Comments from 30-plus Library users, the El Cerrito City Council unanimously voted to continue funding extra hours for our library. The reason for eleven hours, rather than fifteen, is that the County intends to close all branch libraries on Sunday, so the four existing hours on Sunday were not considered.

Their unanimous vote shows the Council understands how important the library is to our community.  Libraries everywhere are “a symbol of the vital connection between knowledge and democracy.”  Our library serves no less a vital function for us in El Cerrito.

The Council’s funding of these eleven additional hours, and the County’s plan to close all branches on Sunday, means the El Cerrito Library will be open 46 hours/six days per week when normal library operation returns.

The tentative  library hours are the same as before except for Sunday:

Monday & Tuesday        – 12:00 to 8:00

Wednesday & Thursday – 10:00 to 6:00

Friday & Saturday          – 10:00 to 5:00

Sunday                           — Closed

Thank you for you timely show of support for our library.

Al Miller
ECLF President

Need your help fight cuts in library hours – here’s how – act by April 15!

Greetings to all El Cerrito Library Supporters:

As a valuable and concerned member of our library community, you signed up, either on this El Cerrito Library Foundation website or at an ECLF booth at a City activity, to receive notification whenever the El Cerrito City Council is scheduled to consider any actions affecting our library. A strong threat to our current 50 hours, seven days per week library operation merits our attention. 

Whether or not you were able to watch the April 7 city council meeting (viewable on the city’s website), the most important item discussed was addressing the fiscal problems of the city as acerbated by the coronavirus pandemic.  The council is looking to cut 5-10% of the budget generally in order to provide both a regular and an emergency reserve (and which was one of the issues that was raised in the recent audit report).  

At that April 7 council meeting, Karen Pinkos, the City Manager, acknowledged that she was going to be recommending that among the things to be cut is the $129,000 that extended the library operating hours from the county provided 35 hours (and 5 days) a week to the current 50 hours (and seven days) a week. She will be reporting back to the next council meeting on April 21 and is almost certainly going to be recommending a complete cutting of the hours because, as she stated, the alternative will be furloughing city staff.  

Now is the time for everyone to tell the city council members of your support for the current 50 hours, seven days per week library hours.  We want to be sure all council members get emails from a large number of people by April 16.  Please, all of you reading this notice, send your emails of support to each council member, the City Manager, and the Assistant City Manager as follows:  Mayor Greg Lyman –; Mayor Pro-Tem Paul Fadelli –; Council Member Janet Abelson –; Council Member Rochelle Pardue-Okimoto –; Council Member Gabriel Quinto –; City Manager Karen Pinkos –; Alexandra Orologas, Assistant City Manager –  (Please BCC your email to Al Miller,

And contact 3-5 of your friends who live in El Cerrito to ask them to also write emails to the above council members in support of the current library hours. Included below are a few sample statements you can use to adapt in your emails:

The most important services provided by our city come from our first responders — the police and fire department.  That’s why we support that no budget cut will adversely affect the level of services provided by them. But this need does not mean we must eliminate city-funded library hours.  There are many other items which can be reduced. Yes, those items will be missed by our residents. But with the exception of our first responders, the library serves the needs of so many El Cerritans and is valued by its community. Public comments at city council meetings over the past several months have shown that El Cerritans with widely varying views about the origin and the solutions to our city’s financial problems all share a desire to continue to fund library hours.

1.  The city-funded hours were passed by the council following the defeat of the library bonds in 2016.  One of the issues in that election was that the library was only open part-time.  The council, when they passed the city-funded issues indicated there were making a commitment to us, the electorate, that a desperately needed new library would be available to El Cerritans on a more full-time basis. To break that commitment at this time will damage the credibility of the council whenever an effort to fund a new library will be on the ballot. In addition, in 2018 the city said that Measure V money would be used to support fire, police and library hours. El Cerrito voted for Measure V and expects to see that promise kept.

2.  The city funded library hours produced an increase in computer logins by over 50% while the logins in the rest of the county library branches were flat. These numbers show just how much access to the internet and computers are needed in our area.  The hours help bridge the digital divide. To cut the hours now would significantly disadvantage the neediest among us, in essence balancing our budget on the backs of our poorest.

3.  The city council has sought a 5-10% budget reduction citywide. The elimination of the city-funded library hours represents a 100% reduction.  A ten percent reduction would reduce hours by 1.5 per week.

4.  The elimination of the city funded library hours might, at best, result in the savings of 1-2 jobs at the city level while causing a similar loss in jobs at the county level.  Both city and county employees serve our residents and the loss of jobs at either level affect us.

5.  Libraries serve as a refuge from the chaos of homelessness for those experiencing homelessness.  Every hour that the library is closed is an hour where that refuge is denied to the most needy among us.

6.  Our library is a valuable cultural, economic, educational, artistic, and community resource.  It is an asset of incalculable value to our community and is one of our busiest and more beloved institutions. But it is only available when open.  

7.  The library is a good community investment.  Studies cited on the website of the California State Librarian indicate that every dollar invested in libraries returns two to ten dollars to the community.

8.  The city-funded hours for the library have results in greater value of the library for all of us — 48,000 additional patron visits year-to-year, 50% increase in library programs, 9,000 additional attendees at library programs (an increase of over 120%), increased funding to the library from the Friends of the El Cerrito Library of $6,800 (170%), and increased donations to the Permanent Endowment Fund of the El Cerrito Library Foundation of nearly $25,000.  

The meeting packet for council members to review for their April 21 meeting will be sent to them by the City Clerk on Thursday, April 16. To be sure your comments are included, please send them before 4:00 pm on Wednesday April 15.

Thank you for your help in our fight for our current library hours.

And, thanks to our City of El Cerrito Designated Library Commissioner, Michael Fisher, for his leadership in developing this request.

Al Miller
President, El Cerrito Library Foundation